Tangentially related, I recently had some hand-me-down high-end full tower speakers lose their integrated subwoofer amps. I bypassed them and wired in an external amp but people said the integrated DSP would be missing. That's when I learned about CamillaDSP [1] and CamillaFIR [2]. I got a calibrated UMIK-1 microphone and did a frequency sweep in the room. Then I applied the Camilla-computed FIR filter to my snapcast-sourced music stream on the Raspberry Pi 3 B I have networked into the living room. Now I have room-corrected and loudspeaker corrected fancy DSP and the speakers sound better than ever. Pretty fun, and very cheap. The Pi3 runs it using about 20% of its CPU. Not bad! I did the same process up in my office with some desk speakers and they sound great too (that time using EasyEffects to apply the filter in real-time rather than CamillaDSP).
FWIW, I've tried Dirac Live and compared it to the correction suggested by REW [0]. In both cases, the measurements were taken with a UMIK-1, and the correction was done on a computer. Contrary to GP, I didn't have to fix borked components, just a random, untreated living room.
Dirac seemed to have a fairly heavy-handed correction. In my case, I only had fairly narrow frequency ranges that needed correcting, but Dirac seemed to move much wider ranges at a time. It's also nearly impossible to tweak; you basically can only increase/decrease "the lows" or "the highs". But maybe I'm missing something.
In contrast, the suggestions produced by REW were loaded in EasyEffects on Linux, and I could tweak everything to my heart's content. But I actually just left it alone, since it was good enough.
> I can't take all of the credit. My little robot intern (Opus 4.5) has been very helpful with the busy work, leaving me free to handle the trickier planning and implementation. ;)
I wonder if you could do the same thing in reverse and have a cheap way to get multiple inputs.
I would love a cheap way to add 8–16 inputs to my PC; all the audio interfaces I found cost quite a bit.
I use a UCA202 for the same purpose. Does yours output static sometimes when it sits for too long? Based on my testing this seems to be a Linux thing instead of a Behringer thing.
I wonder if 264/520 kB RAM is also enough for a high quality parametric stereo reverb/echo effect? Should fit about 3/6 seconds of uncompressed 16-bit 44.1/48 kHz audio.
Also: Raspberry Pi Ltd - please keep increasing the RAM size in future iterations to unlock even more use cases.
Tangentially related, I recently had some hand-me-down high-end full tower speakers lose their integrated subwoofer amps. I bypassed them and wired in an external amp but people said the integrated DSP would be missing. That's when I learned about CamillaDSP [1] and CamillaFIR [2]. I got a calibrated UMIK-1 microphone and did a frequency sweep in the room. Then I applied the Camilla-computed FIR filter to my snapcast-sourced music stream on the Raspberry Pi 3 B I have networked into the living room. Now I have room-corrected and loudspeaker corrected fancy DSP and the speakers sound better than ever. Pretty fun, and very cheap. The Pi3 runs it using about 20% of its CPU. Not bad! I did the same process up in my office with some desk speakers and they sound great too (that time using EasyEffects to apply the filter in real-time rather than CamillaDSP).
[1] https://github.com/HEnquist/camilladsp
[2] https://github.com/VilhoValittu/CamillaFIR
Did you ever use Dirac Live and can compare the results? Hardware that supports Dirac is unfortunately very expensive.
FWIW, I've tried Dirac Live and compared it to the correction suggested by REW [0]. In both cases, the measurements were taken with a UMIK-1, and the correction was done on a computer. Contrary to GP, I didn't have to fix borked components, just a random, untreated living room.
Dirac seemed to have a fairly heavy-handed correction. In my case, I only had fairly narrow frequency ranges that needed correcting, but Dirac seemed to move much wider ranges at a time. It's also nearly impossible to tweak; you basically can only increase/decrease "the lows" or "the highs". But maybe I'm missing something.
In contrast, the suggestions produced by REW were loaded in EasyEffects on Linux, and I could tweak everything to my heart's content. But I actually just left it alone, since it was good enough.
---
[0] https://www.roomeqwizard.com/
This is awesome.
What are the odds a Raspberry Pi could keep up with BTrack?
https://github.com/adamstark/BTrack
Looks like output only and only one stereo pair from USB is processed to outputs, but a really cool project.
Also, for those watching for it: https://www.audiosciencereview.com/forum/index.php?threads/i...
> I can't take all of the credit. My little robot intern (Opus 4.5) has been very helpful with the busy work, leaving me free to handle the trickier planning and implementation. ;)
I’ve been wanting to follow this tutorial for some time. I think this might make the whole thing way simpler and smaller if all I want is line in.
https://www.raspberrypi.com/news/upcycle-a-sonos-play1/
I wonder if you could do the same thing in reverse and have a cheap way to get multiple inputs. I would love a cheap way to add 8–16 inputs to my PC; all the audio interfaces I found cost quite a bit.
The ADCs on RP2040/2350 only have 12 bit resolution.
I recently bought a Behringer U-phono UFO202 as a cheap DAC for my mini pc. Can this Pi thing replace it?
I use a UCA202 for the same purpose. Does yours output static sometimes when it sits for too long? Based on my testing this seems to be a Linux thing instead of a Behringer thing.
This Pi thing does not have a DAC.
Nice.
I wonder if 264/520 kB RAM is also enough for a high quality parametric stereo reverb/echo effect? Should fit about 3/6 seconds of uncompressed 16-bit 44.1/48 kHz audio.
Also: Raspberry Pi Ltd - please keep increasing the RAM size in future iterations to unlock even more use cases.
The RP2350 (Pico 2) supports external PSRAM so you can add several MB more there if you need it.
Is there a guaranteed latency?
85ms
https://github.com/WeebLabs/DSPi/commit/ba8e481570e6a5ce3d35...
Ouch, thats pretty average, what a pity ..
And here's the release thread for those of you wanting a bit more detail or to talk with the creator: https://www.audiosciencereview.com/forum/index.php?threads/i...