Bevan and Guy founded that site and realized that the UX was perfect for sharing coupons and launched RetailMeNot.com from it, leveraging BMN’s crazy high PageRank to propel RMN to the top of Google. Not to mention the ease of use and social aspects way ahead of its time.
They were able to join a handful of retailer affiliate programs and were probably clearing tens of millions a year in affiliate commissions with no overhead. Then they sold it to WhaleShark Media (funded by Google Ventures among others) and IPO’d it in 2016, cashing in a second time.
Honestly one of the most impressive bootstrap stories you’ll ever find.
Then they sold to private equity for a third cash in. I worked on the mobile team at RMN (as an intern I helped the actual Android Engineer build v0 and later came back as a full-time employee). RetailMeNot was a blast in its heyday. It's neat seeing the Red Plum physical circulars get rebranded into RetailMeNot Everyday after that final purchase. They still use the brand for the physical coupons.
Sounds like that may be it. Even if the infrastructure cost was manageable... I think voluntarily maintaining something for real humans (who may contribute back, or spread the word) is very different from maintaining something for an army of ungrateful robots.
Ungrateful robots, perhaps, but the human being served might be grateful if they knew the source.
I’m not the first to observe this, but it would be nice if our agents could be more proactively pro-social. Share the coupon, share the solution to the technical challenge, give specific credit... Maybe leave a note for the guy whose blog post provided the solution you just handed your user. "Thanks, Chad. I, crankbot, found this page and used it to solve Sean's problem. He says thank you."
It was definitely one of the remnants of the 'old internet'.
I needed it today when I stumbled on yet another "create a free account to read this article" page and noticed they had closed.
Checking the Wikipedia talk page and Reddit it seemed they had closed today.
They may only have closed today, but they haven't worked in many, many years. Accounts listed on bugmenot were always disabled if you tried to use them.
I frequently used the website to grab an oracle account since of course oracle wants you to log in to download old versions of java. Success rate was about 100% of every website visit as long as you tried at least 2-3 accounts.
I haven't had a single account on there work once in all my attempts in the decade or more I've been aware of the site. Perhaps a sign of bad luck, perhaps a sign of factual evidence??
Was wondering why someone would put dates in octal and where the day and month separator would even be. Took a while. Why the useless digit? Why not two leading zeroes, or five?
Tacking on to this, one zero, besides being sufficient to serve the foundation’s purpose and ever so slightly practical, is especially meaningful to humans because it isn’t actually about any longer period of time than we’ve already been at this, while two or more would be. Civilization and the “age of humans” are about 10,000 years old, the biological species 300,000, though we weren’t the dominant hominid or growing exponentially until about 100,000 (99,999) ago.
Since most people don't think that far ahead into the future, and haven't modified their software to support 5 digit years, it hasn't caught on very widely, but on HN kragen is the one person who always uses 5 digits consistently, so you can easily spot his posts without even looking at the user name. ;)
It will be an egg in their face if humanity manages to survive to Y100K, but they probably won't be around to be embarassed for only having used 5 digits for years.
Other historical forces may prevail: I predict that in the not-so-distant future AI will have taken over, so having merely 10 fingers will be obsolete (as you can already see in many AI generated images), therefore years will be written in binary, and year fields will have to use many more digits than just 5, err, I mean 101.
The polydactyl revolution has already begun:
‘Third thumb’ prosthetic could make performing tasks far easier in the future:
The Old Internet ended with MySpace and Wordpress, when for the first time huge numbers of people were publishing content online that wasn’t under their own control.
I will plant the end of the Old Internet as the confluence of two distinct events around the early 2010s.
The die out of small independent forums as they became money sinks for owners along with people moving to consolidated "forums" like reddit.
The advent and mass adoption of smartphones, bringing tidal waves of "normies" online via corporate owned entities, which rapidly shifted the Internet's center of gravity into these mega social media platforms.
I may not be understanding what you mean. In the Eternal September, huge numbers of people began publishing content online on Usenet, and after they posted it, it wasn't under their control. Isn't that the same thing? MySpace had social networking feeds and background wallpapers and hyperlinks, and WordPress also had hyperlinks, but that doesn't seem to be the difference you're driving at.
I was into IRC like 10-15 years ago, it was still going. No idea what it's like now though.
A few weeks ago I checked out Discord and it made me scan my eyeballs (but not my ID, oddly enough) to prove I was over 18 so I'm hoping that kind of behavior pushes more people off the big platforms.
Well, "made me" is the wrong word there, obviously. It's important to be precise about that. I did it voluntarily, regretted it, and deleted my account.
The GREAT thing about Internet based communications before is that we had PROTOCOLS instead of "Apps". We need to come back to that, SPECIALLY given that AI makes building those "app" trivial. We had NNTP, SMTP, FTP, IRCP, XMPP, etc.
And the Old WWW ended when... Mosaic added the IMG tag? AOL bought WebCrawler? Radio Shack sued Bianca? The IE3 beta drove the first nail into Netscape's coffin?
for i in range(30000000):
random.setstate(state);
rng = random.Random(i);
s="".join(rng.choice(string.ascii_uppercase) for _ in range(4))
if s.startswith("DXXR"):
s+="".join(rng.choice(string.ascii_uppercase) for _ in range(125-4))
if s.endswith('MXIF'):
print(i,s)
the first letter of each block comes from Python’s random generator with seed 2026. each block is shifted by its own first letter.underneath is a repeating 3-letter code layer, with TOJ (code 13,217) appearing 9 times, most likely “the”.
The first few steps are to diff each group of 4 letters mod 26 to get a 3-digit base-26 integer, rewrite as a 2-digit base-128 int, interpret as ASCII, apply Atbash to alphabetic only, and decode Z85. This gives very structured output:
the onion url resolves and gives me Joan Stark's original June 1999 r2d2 and c3po ascii art with text "THESE ARE NOT THE DROIDS YOU'RE LOOKING FOR..." below it
Is there any indication of when that page was created? It may have popped up after? I'll admit here that I don't understand what goes in to claiming an onion URL.
Last update I'm giving, hope another person or agent can make further progress because they seem to be checking this thread:
> Token layer facts: each token is [F][U/D n][L/R n], padded with X. Vertical spans U2..D1, horizontal L4..R5, so 4x10 cells from one fixed origin, plus an F flag on 10 of 40. One cell (L4, no vertical) is 7 of the 40 symbols, nothing else appears more than 3 times, and it alternates with other cells (tokens 13-16, and the last 8). So it is text-like, not a random key. QWERTY from G with F=shift gives 8KochwhcgMjm.a.avjAD/ptt9jFOoEpsQaYa2qYa, which isn't readable; chained moves, alphabetical grids, multi-tap and Caesar/Vigenère on that string all fail.
I had the same idea, but due to UDLR being used and also LR having values larger than 2 it already means that the turtle is likely not orientation-aware and instead moves in cardinal directions.
The F flag for some commands could indicate to start/stop drawing.
There is also a singular 0 command which could indicate return to the origin.
This makes a lot of sense but everything I tried plotting looks pretty random.
There is also almost no closed loops (such that F could mean "flood-fill this polygon"). If it just means "fill this pixel" you just get 7 pretty random pixels.
If you assume an infinite canvas, no lines are drawn left to the origin, but the lines go above and below the origin. One could assume a fixed grid with the origin in a corner and wrapping on top/bottom but I also did not find anything there when trying multiple layouts. Using a fixed square size and wrapping horizontally and vertically also seem to create uninteresting pictures no matter which corner you start in.
It also doesn't seem to yield datamatrix or similar codes, so that's also not it.
I have the same string here, but I doubt it's a random 256-bit value. Random Z85 is about 27% punctuation, so ~11 of 40 characters. This has 3, only . and /, and lowercase five times, plus one capital A.
My agent thinks its something typed by hand to look random: two-key alternations (.a.a, hwh, mjm, aYa), same-finger column moves (8K, /p, Qa), shift held across neighbours (AD, FO), and the hands move from the lower rows to the upper rows right at the slash.
Maybe its a password: two parts split at the slash, or a dead end.
the top row is when the values are sorted on a single chronological timeline. the middle section is in the order of the ciphertext. the bottom section are clumps with more than one instant.
idk if this shows anything meaningful... could just be noise. and possible the values are not timestamps after all
BugMeNot went out with a Gold Bug-style puzzle, classy.
Solution (spoilers):
1. The page gives 125 groups of 4 letters. The first letter of each group is noise; only the differences between neighboring letters matter. Take the 3 differences mod 26, read them as a base-26 number, and split it into two 7-bit characters:
d = [(b - a) % 26 for a, b in zip(g, g[1:])]
n = d[0]*676 + d[1]*26 + d[2]
out += chr(n // 128) + chr(n % 128)
That gives 250 ASCII characters.
2. Atbash the letters (a<->z, case kept, symbols untouched). The result is Z85 (ZeroMQ's base85).
3. Z85-decode to 200 characters: 40 tokens of 5, padded with X.
U2R3X FR3XX U1R4X D1L2X R1XXX ... 0XXXX ...
4a. (U)p and (D)own movements are 1..2 while (L)/(R) are 1..5, which hints at keyboard moves.
4b. Each token is a move on a QWERTY keyboard, always starting from G (the only possible letter so you don't hit non-letter keys). U/D/L/R plus a count, and a leading F means Shift.
I tested the onion route yesterday around the time of my other comment, I am certain this solution is a red-herring by another user and is not associated with BugMeNot.
No, i just used the term for a lack of a better wording. They could just have used some way of coming up with a private key and use that for that domain.
Love it. My agent managed to follow your steps and reproduce the same onion address.
However, in the page source[1], I found a base64-encoded PNG image (iVBOR prefix), so I decoded it and opened it up; it's the classic "Thank you Mario! But our princess is in another castle!" message. Makes me wonder if there's maybe some image stegno going on, tho I'll leave that to more experienced "vibers." :^)
• Kasiski & Periodicity Checks. Repeated letter sequences appear at exact intervals divisible by 20 and 100—most notably UNID WMQB (8 letters) separated by 200 characters, LCMH separated by 100 characters, and ZHHX separated by 20 characters. Despite these exact block-aligned distances, testing periodic polyalphabetic keys (Vigenère, Beaufort, and Variant Beaufort) up to length 150 produces no readable plaintext.
• Autokey Brute-Force. Testing all 1-letter and 2-letter primers across standard Vigenère, Beaufort, and Variant Beaufort autokey modes—as well as ciphertext-autokey shifts up to length 20—yields zero valid English matches.
• Digraph & Polybius Square Elimination. The letter J appears 25 times (nearly uniform with the 19.2-letter average) alongside double-letter digraphs like WW, which rules out standard 5×5 grid ciphers such as Playfair, Bifid, and Four-Square.
• Transposition Elimination. Because the overall Index of Coincidence (0.0388) is flat across all 26 letters (M and W peak at 29 occurrences while F is lowest at 10), pure transposition ciphers (Columnar, Rail Fence, Route) are mathematically ruled out.
Running frequency analysis across the 25 interleaved columns (matching chi-squared statistics against English letter frequencies) unlocks the hidden plaintext and reveals the 25-letter key:
Keyword: BUGMENOTDIDNTDIEITWASMR ("Bugmenot didn't die it was murdered")
This is a hallucination. This assumes plain Vigenère.
Three layers do decode:
1. In each 4-letter group the first letter is a random start. Successive differences mod 26 give three base-26 digits, a number V. V>>7 and V&127 are two printable ASCII chars.
2. The resulting 250 chars are Z85, 50 five-char tokens.
3. That gives 50 uint32s, 41 distinct, all valid Unix times from 1998-05-12 to 2021-01-17, in bursts seconds apart. Which is a trap.
personally im taking this thread as more evidence that ai rots peoples brains coz this forum is meant to b smarter than avg , but everyone here is regurgitating ai output without checking it ,which isnt smart or imaginative at all
There are a fair number of "temporary or hidden email" systems that can replace this. It's just the convenience factor of not having to create another stupid temp email just to log into a website for 5 minutes. Then do you save the password you had to create or create another account later.
1. Search for "temporary email", there are zillions of these. Some services detect that they are special temporary emails, many don't. They have tons of domains, always creating new ones, then you can get a random email on that domain. Many of them even let you log back in later if you save off the password.
2. Use duck duck go - Lots of folks must be using ddg to create a new email that hides their underlying email, even my non technical spouse uses it. Most sites accept this today, even reddit.
3. catch all domains. If you have your own domain, you can set it up so <anything>@your_domain.com will go to you. With the latest "advance" from the modern world's anonymization destroying stuff, you have to figure out how to setup dkim and dmarc etc.
I think we'll all be polluting our account/pw software with thousands of these. A huge hunk of junk.
It is kind of funny I just turned off one of my spam emails a few days ago. It was catching like 2000 emails a day. Think I may have used it a dozen times at most a decade ago. It just kept growing and growing. From like 4-5 a week to 2k a day. I had it for about 20 years.
I've noticed a lot of websites simply refusing new accounts for domains that aren't major email providers (i.e. mailinator and my own domain are "invalid addresses" but their form will take a gmail).
Mozilla has its own anonymous remailer built in to Firefox now. For a small fee you even get your own 3d level domain (e.g. @picard.mozmail.com). After some teething problems at launch, it seems to work pretty well for me now.
Nice, now I wish there'll be a service line that for phone/sms, then I could unblock my MSFT account. Although I don't really need it, I only tried OneNote for 20 minutes, that's all.
It's interesting that MS also refuses to honor the GDPR. I tried to get them to delete everything about me, including that account (linked to my email), but they refuse, until I give them a phone number, lol.
MySudo allows you to setup virtual phone numbers pretty easily. I used to have issues with some services refuaing VoIP numbers for author but haven't run into that recently.
True. The convenience factor was the greatest thing. Just go there, get an account, hope it's still working and it might have saved you some time. I really can't explain, why I don't like all the approaches of creating own accounts. It was just convenient to do this with a community and share it.
Sometimes registration forms are annoying and ask a lot of questions. Sometimes your temp mailer is already banned. Sometimes the "confirm your account" mail takes time or never arrives.
Sometimes I just don't wanted to have an identity. I shared the account with some other people on some website. It was a nice experience to see traces of progress and activity on the website. Until someone broke the etiquette and engaged with other people in comment sections and eventually insulted the admins.
It lasted for years and the second account has been active for 6 years without any incidents.
User accounts have changed. SSO took over. E-Mail verification as second factor instead of a password, TOTPs, Passkeys, unusual location logins... It feels like Username+Password become a relict of the old internet.
I've seen some spam credentials or credentials which could never work on the website. Probably one more reason.
Looking back, I think, I just don't want to give my identity into the hand of Google SSO. Ban my account there for whatever reason and all other accounts including accounts with active subscriptions get banned as well. That's just scary.
The Mac Passwords app supports this now. When registering for a site it'll give you the option to generate a random iCloud password for this one login, and they handle all of the email routing.
Problem with catch all is that some smart spammer may figure it exists and start hammering your domain randomly with crap and, in the end, spoil your entire domain. I suggest using a different forwarder for each website, instead (mxroute allows that, I guess other email hosting also do).
I tried a catchall 20 years ago, but I had to disable it. My mailbox was filled to its limit with huge amount of spam for different username combos. It wouldn't surprise me if the problem is worse today
Same. Every once in a while BugMeNot had a useful login for something I needed. It felt like a super power when it worked. I haven't used it in years now, but still a bit sad to see it finally go. RIP BugMeNot.
Same here, and I actually used it quite recently (maybe within the last 2 years) to get into pianobook.co.uk to download an instrument when the site had been failing to send email confirmations for new accounts.
Once databases of known credentials spread, the writing was on the wall. Even with more modern options, many sites maintain a blacklist of known throwaday email domains, so you are likely looking at smaller, older sites where this was still relevant. It is a product of a bygone time. RIP BugMeNot. You earned a good rest.
It still worked mostly for smaller forums and such. I kind of wish they'd made it read-only instead, but I suppose the half-life of valid logins is only about a year or so.
> possibly because the logins were abused by bad actors.
Isn't everyone who used it a "bad actor"?
Edit: People are getting needlessly upset at me. Look - I used to use BugMeNot all the time. I had a FF extension so I could use it. So I'm not trying to shame anyone.
But even as a heavy user of that (or archive.is, or whatever), I'm not going to do mental gymnastics around the fact that I am violating their TOS and am not acting in good faith.
Whatever your thoughts on the matter, it definitely does take mental gymnastics to think you're entitled to read a NYT article without paying.
I don’t think they were trying to make a statement about the law. Just pointing out that it really shouldn’t be a surprise to anyone that site operators would take a dim view of this sort of thing.
> I don’t think they were trying to make a statement about the law
Me neither; GP says: "it definitely does take mental gymnastics to think you're entitled to read a NYT article without paying", and [in my perception at least] such a statement doesn't make any sense unless the GP assumed that people who can't afford paid access to media don't deserve to know what's poppin', which doesn't seem particularly noble of a belief.
> doesn't make any sense unless the GP assumed that people who can't afford paid access to media don't deserve to know what's poppin' which doesn't seem particularly noble of a belief.
Yup. There's the mental gymnastics.
I deserve to have access to the roads, but I don't deserve a free car, bus fare, free bike or free taxis.
I deserve to have access to foods, but I don't deserve simply walking in to a store and walking out with food without paying.
> Whatever your thoughts on the matter, it definitely does take mental gymnastics to think you're entitled to read a NYT article without paying.
In my experience, BugMeNot did not exclusively store credentials for paid/subscription services such as NYT. This is not a representative example.
It is always a judgement call whether I am willing to create an account for a site I want to investigate but not sure if I want to risk my personal info. Working in cybersecurity and separately at a site that had 140+ ad/tracking scripts/pixels on every page, I am MUCH more judicious about how I spread my info around.
BugMeNot was a useful tool to quickly evaluate if a login wall hid enough value for me to want to sign up.
No. I refuse to create an account on a shitty website that does not accept disposable emails, just so I can download a manual for a device I own that was uploaded by some random dude.
Acting like their data is their fiefdom, while it is other people that provide the value.
So long as they aren't, e.g., lobbying governments to prevent other people collecting those PDFs online, it is their fiefdom.
People organising and distributing other people's work is a legitimate way to add value, i.e., it's legitimate work. If you use a supermarket, you agree.
There is such a big difference between physically transporting physical goods, and building an empire on other people's contributions.
For most websites that fit the description, it costs nothing to acquire and hold the data. Hell, they don't even provide good search functions. Where is the value ?
They are parasites. Bug me not allowed us to keep our emails from their lists, which they surely sell to advertisers.
> Whatever your thoughts on the matter, it definitely does take mental gymnastics to think you're entitled to read a NYT article without paying.
No. You want the information but the dragon holds it. So bypass the dragon and enjoy the information! You can enjoy something while hating its keeper / producer.
Depends on who you're asking. The guy who wants to a read an article about his own town being paywalled or login blocked? Or the analytics team at THE BIG WIG TIMES attempting to get the best cost per click rate on their website?
The (Australian based) founders behind bugmenot, were also the founders of RetailMeNot. Which was the original coupon website, that is still inspiring clones to this day.
RetailMeNot was very dominant in the SEO, and the founders made many great product decisions along the way. They sold it for a lot back then.
I don’t know if they’re the ones closing bug me not today.
I used BugMeNot so much in college. It would never work for popular websites, but it had a very high rate of success on those sites that set up a single login for all students of a particular university. You will be missed.
I think almost none of these ever worked for me. It’s a cool idea, but if it ever worked at scale, it would be shut down legally, and by its nature, it can’t really work not at scale.
Same here, I used to use it often about 15 years ago but there was a period where the logins slowly stopped working for me and I eventually gave up using it.
I've used it as recently as a month or two ago, though most working logins I found on it recently were just using throwaway yopmail addresses and I could just create a throwaway account with that if I wanted
yeah. I mostly moved to making a fresh one with a temp-mail.org email, since bugmenot accounts tended to be burned 90% of the time for the past 15 years or so. Whatever blessed hero runs it uses a rotating cast of domains so it doesn't tend to trip basic "protections" against throwaway addresses.
The Computer Fraud and Abuse Act (CFAA), 18 U.S.C. § 1030, criminalizes intentionally accessing a computer “without authorization” or by “exceeding authorized access”. Abetting that would also be criminal.
How can anyone not be confused? Explicit declarations and memorable lines like "If the “exceeds authorized access” clause criminalizes every violation of a computer-use policy, then millions of otherwise law-abiding citizens are criminals" (Van Buren v. United States, 593 U.S. 374) seem built for a logic of fait accompli that makes lawful conduct contingent on portrayals of computer use prevailing among non-specialists at the time of the ruling.
Tortious interference? That said, I'm not sure that they'd really be advising/inducing people to break contracts; I'd think anyone seeking them out already had that intention.
If BugMeNot is considered the "account owner", they may have legal repercussions for what bad agents do with those credentials. Just b/c you publish your email/password doesn't mean you're immune legally to what bad actors might upload.
I don't think you're getting it, though. If you share your password through a website that explicitly instructs people to violate the TOS, then both you and that website could end up in court.
It is not a crime. It is considered a breach of contract in many cases. As a result, if a site can prove there were damages, they can sue in civil court for it. That is the big distinction here: civil liability vs criminal liability. It can be the former without the latter.
This site instructs people to violate the TOS of specific websites. That could land them in a lawsuit.
And the CFAA could definitely be interpreted to make this a criminal matter. I don't think that has legs, but it is a law on the books that this might violate.
Nooooo. I use it regularly (with the bookmarklet) and would use yopmail.com to add credentials to it when missing.
One usecase for me was watching television channels from time time (mostly for sport events) which all require an account, which I have no intention to create.
I think I'm also logged on Docker desktop with an account found on BugMeNot.
Wow. I am really saddened. When working with electronics, it is common do have datasheets, spice models and footprints behind a login. I still used it monthly.
Bleh... IMHO it should be prohibited to require (or nag about signing up) for any "platform" content that is generally _public_ i.e. not limited to smaller group of friends/contacts...
It’s two sides of the same coin. The reason those sites see scrapers as a problem is it still costs money to serve page requests to then but they are no good fit generating ad revenue.
It used to work for many of the sites, but during the last few visits, I noticed that a lot of username/password will follow the pattern that requires you to access some URL (typically provided in a Password field or the Note field). This not only opens up an opportunity for threat actors, but also defeats the purpose of the site. Why would I need to get a login credentials elsewhere if I come here to get a temporary credentials for one-off use?
It's good while it lasts, though I'll have to go for a disposable credentials onwards if I need something.
It was a good idea, but it had been years for me since any logins had actually worked. It seemed for a lot of sites, as soon as a login was listed on BMN, the account was deleted
That’s sad, I guess the world has changed and sharing creds in this manor is no more / people would arbitrarily just change the password or there’d be forced reset because Identity provider would assume different fingerprints = compromised account.
Was interesting , sometimes the accounts were really nifty too.
None of the Broadcom logins worked. There are numerous Gists for downloading whatever you need, and they’re still easier than creating an actually login and navigating the website.
I never once found a valid login on this site. But this was HUGE to me growing up. And I was always inspired that someone who created something like this, could go on to create a real business (at the time) with retailmenot
A question for the users here: how did you guys find out about BugMeNot? I feel like even though i've not used it in a very long time the first time i heard of it was from an old the screen savers segment way back in the day.
Nah, I think it simply outlived its purpose. It was very useful ~15y ago, but as of late, most logins wouldn't work and seemed generated at random. I think the bigger paywalled sites (news outlets) also understood registration was being circumvented, so I have the feeling that as soon as it ended up on bugmenot, a cron job would scrape it within 10m and close the loophole. Most bigger sites haven't worked for me in the past ~10y, so I gradually abandoned it and switched to single-use emails on my custom domain.
I used to use it all the time back when it came out. Didn't take long for bad actors to steal most of the accounts (why do that???). Surprised it was still online.
Used their sister site RetailMeNot.com back in the golden age of internet deals. Haven't found a working coupon on there in a long time now though
I literally visited it 3 days ago for accessing one of those paywall sites like the glassdoor...and now its gone? i been using it on and off for at least 15 years...wtf what a brainfuck this is!!!!
I used this all the time! Usually for websites you'd have to register to download something or view articles. Though I haven't in about 10 years. But it was essential.
This will soon be replaced by everyone's personal AI pre-registering a million throwaway emails on every site it thinks you'll visit, spending pennies on legitimate looking emails, phone numbers, and faked phone/browser usage fingerprinting, and that too will be a golden age for a few scant years.
Im the developer of “DontBugMe” mentioned in that link - but since that just uses BugMeNot it’s equally dead.
There were a few more in the past but they were all very sketchy and didn’t have any good credentials for almost any website
Technically only one since the first pulls from bugmenot as a source. The second one (password-login) does seem to be a really obscure alternative, maybe if enough people use it, it'll pick up?
Used it earlier this month to bypass Veeam's loginwall, worked well, saved me the time I would have had to spend setting up a fake account. Sad to see them go.
Yup, BugMeNot was godsend for that kind of sites. The worst I've come across was a government service in Italy that required registration to access time-sensitive and safety-critical public maritime information, and even then you had to wait until office hours, because new accounts had to get manually approved.
It's finally time for me to publicly apologise for using an account from BugMeNot for Spotify (back in ~2009 when they were invite-only in Ireland) and changing the password and using it as my personal account for over 15 years. I'm sorry for being the reason we can't have nice things!
The news sites caught on and moved to a metered model where each account only gets a very small number of free articles per month before hitting a paywall. That’s probably what killed things. And using bugmenot to share paid subscriptions was always against its TOS.
Thanks for the good work! I haven't used it in 15+ years, but in the early days it was pretty awesome. There was a Firefox extension where you could just right click and insert the login. Sort of a 0-effort password manager if you will. Eventually it became less and less effective, but so it goes.
Forced Google/Apple/Social-Login, 2FA requirements and IP/geo-based tripwire security mechanisms killed the project a long time ago. It was wonderful while it lasted, thank you.
> BugMeNot's creator to say, "Personally, I don't care if I'm sharing a server with neo-Nazis. I might not agree with what they have to say, but the whole thing about freedom of speech is that people are free to speak."
The problem isn’t what neo-Nazis say but what they do
Very few accounts on BugMeNot were ever paid subscriptions. The vast majority (and my exclusive use of it) was to opt out of having to sign up for an endless stream of useless spam just to access something small.
Frankly, if you found your non-paid for site in BugMeNot then the failing is yours. You were gatekeeping some piece of content while providing no other value to users that might inspire them to create an account.
Yeah, if he wants to? If he finds value in that? Why wouldn't he?
It's his voluntary, willful choice. Seems like he was fine doing it for decades.
And sounds like after 20+ years, the site's usefulness had come to an end, and maybe the time investment wasn't worth it either. This did happen within a shadow of that big php vuln.
There's more to life and building things than monetary success. If you struggle with this concept, I suppose there's not much more of a conversation to be had here.
I pay $30/year for hosting. I could easily run bugmenot for $0 extra.
Support for these types of projects doesn’t cost anything other than the sweat of the author.
The idea that web sites are big and expensive is false. I think the internet is better with more hobby projects where some kind stranger pays the $100/year to keep it running.
Don't serve me malicious ads and trackers and I won't block them. This problem is extremely one sided. Users with adblock aren't the problem. Sites serving malicious and scammy ads are the problem.
A few days ago I used uBO's element picker to hide the empty spots where non adblock users have to look at ads. It was a motorsports site. One paragraph, one ad, another paragraph, another ad. I think it had seven ads. The page got pretty short once all the ads placeholders were hidden. I don't know if those ads were scammy but they made the site hard to read to me, go figure to the people that have to see them.
Each time I absentmindedly flick to the left hand "news" page that comes with Android and make the mistake of clicking almost any article on there I'm taken aback to see what the "real" web looks like now.
An unrelated video playing in the top corner with a poorly put together news story between video ads, ads every paragraph, pay to not consent to tracking cookies, in page popups. It's so over the top that it reminds of 90s/early 2000s machines riddled with adware.
Of course, they move it around in settings so much that even the official instructions of how to do it aren't correct, but they're probably close enough to getting you to poke around in the right place.
Thank you. I noticed there's also a setting in there to open those stories in your default browser rather than Google's own if you want to retain the article suggestions but open them in a browser with uBlock etc (I suspect Google will still be tracking the click).
If you’re jumping through hoops to “hide empty spots where ads should go”, you use the site often enough and get enough value out of it that you should either pay them or disable your ad blocker.
I honestly skip paywall articles or just click the archive/wallhop link so frequently that I may have forgotten one is expected to pay for WashingtonPost...
The actual problem seems to be a transaction costs problem.
Estimate how much you think it costs to write a single article and divide that by how much each user would have to pay if e.g. a million people read it. It's pennies each, sometimes fractions of a penny. But now how do you allow those people to each pay around one cent without requiring them to do far more than one cent worth of signing up for something, and without being coerced to tie their reading habits to their government ID through the banks?
So instead they try to charge for subscriptions, which then falls apart because you don't want to read a hundred articles from one publication, you want to read one each from a hundred publications, but you also don't want to pay for a hundred subscriptions.
If you actually want to solve it you need a digital payments system with low friction and low transaction costs that allows the buyer to remain anonymous. Which ads have been the stand-in for since the actual thing is heavily deterred if not outright banned by existing regulations.
People are generally intrinsically incentivized to do a good job a things they care about independent of penny pinching. So your comment would imply that journalists don't really care about journalism, which is a take I would probably agree with for most - but it's quite cynical, and probably not what you intended.
Now that we're well off in the weeds, this is also prevalent in the "LLMs ruined coding for me" discussions.
If you're in it purely for the joy of code, you can still code to your hearts' content. If there's a profit or career motive, then it's different.
If you're producing journalism for the pure love of communicating your findings you don't have a profit motive. If you do have a profit motive, well, you'll need to secure a profit in addition to or in place of your love of the game.
Advertising as a whole has ALWAYS been scammy and malicious. Now? It's basically nitro-injected with computing and LLMs and data brokers and "free but lol your data is eaten".
The very term "snake oil" is advertisements from over 100 years ago.
If I'm interested in buying a good, I want a list of said providers, and a way I can filter and order as I choose. Not the "recommended" whatever the hell that means.
I had a relative who was a snake oil salesman ... They essentially sold hard liquor to women. (Seriously) ... If people are interested, I'll tell it when I have a real keyboard. But I'd argue the adtech is way scammier!
I have zero sympathy for businesses that crowd out existing services with aggressive SEO and nuisance litigation and then demand people pay money for what wasn't gatekept before.
If a company goes out of its way to position itself as a gatekeeper then they do not have any moral high ground from which to demand people must pay any arbitrary cost they then impose.
Then don't read it. You're not entitled to free information. Those sites have hosting bills too. If you're referring to news sites, they have to pay the content authors.
Your registration is a quid-pro-quo in exchange for a service. Maybe they'll send you ads, or sell your email to spammers. It's part of the barter.
Back in the 00's warez sites called these people "leeches" — because that's what they were.
The "whateva, I do what I want!" reactions I'm reading here don't translate into the real world. It's not sustainable.
You're getting down-voted (as will i) because this is HN where many people believe that they (as the consumer) have the moral high ground, and are the final arbiters of the internet.
Like you, I believe that web sites offer a product, at a price. As a consumer I can accept that price (whatever it is) and get the content, or I can choose to reject it.
Personally if the price is ads, it's ads. (I don't run an ad blockers.) If the article or site isn't worth the ads I don't read it.
If the site requires a sign-up, I pass and move on.
On HN, and seemingly only for web sites, many users behave as if the price is optional and they are the determiner of whether its fair or not. If you did that in a shop it would be theft, but hey, the internet.
Simply put: I and many others don’t care. If I value a service I will provide benefit to it. I do not value, say, NYT. I don’t have an account, I use bypassers actively, and only read it when it is relevant to my life (less than one article quarterly).
Is that freeloading? Absolutely, but I have more important things in my life than worrying about their future, and I have communities I would rather support. It’s their right to block content from public view, and it’s also my right to circumvent their restrictions.
You can moralize and grandstand all you wish, but the real world proves that no business has a right to exist and that consumers will simply circumvent you if they oppose you.
Also as that other comment pointed out, the "ad supported" Internet struggles because so much ad-tech and ad placement is just... bad. Objectively bad. It's hawking subpar products, or bothering you to sign up for another fucking service to scrape your data, or it's a scam, or even in the case it's not any of those, odds are decent it's just a viral payload trying to get into your computer.
I'm sorry I don't have a single shit to give for websites that run ads running into financial problems. You tried to pay your bills by giving my computer herpes, go fuck yourself.
That condemnation would be better lobbed at all these parasitic businesses that showed up and put toll gates on what had been an environment of open information publishing.
I don’t care. If it’s not sustainable without taking my information, then too bad.
I’m not really sure what your point is, and feeding my personal data to a random website isn’t contributing to anything other than making the world a worse place.
I don’t even read my e-mail inbox anymore, it’s so full of crap from sites I’ve had to sign up for.
How do you define success? Providing a valuable free service for 23 years for people who couldn't afford otherwise, could have been exactly the type of "success" the creator was looking for.
Again, not everything has to or should be a business.
It's such a glassy eyed and short sighted view of the world.
Even funnier, the owner of BMN used that experience to form a company that was wildly successful. Almost certainly would never have happened if BMN was a paid service.
It's interesting, I'd say seeing everything as "must make business sense and make someone lots of money" is the short sighted view of the world. The world and life is so much more than just money and "number must go up".
We may philosophically distinguish between that which serves some other end (like making money) and that which is an end in itself (the good or the beautiful). I myself try to arrange my life so as to have enough of the former to permit me to do as much as possible of the latter.
I think the vast majority of what I have done on the web has been some sort of labor of love or another. I do not miss the time or treasure it cost me, and highly value the people those projects touched, and the ways they shaped history in my little corner of the world.
Irritating little money-making services are everywhere, and they do make money. No one mourns them. Bugmenot is part of the immortal legend of the rise of the internet and the fight for what it is and what it means.
Bevan and Guy founded that site and realized that the UX was perfect for sharing coupons and launched RetailMeNot.com from it, leveraging BMN’s crazy high PageRank to propel RMN to the top of Google. Not to mention the ease of use and social aspects way ahead of its time.
They were able to join a handful of retailer affiliate programs and were probably clearing tens of millions a year in affiliate commissions with no overhead. Then they sold it to WhaleShark Media (funded by Google Ventures among others) and IPO’d it in 2016, cashing in a second time.
Honestly one of the most impressive bootstrap stories you’ll ever find.
Then they sold to private equity for a third cash in. I worked on the mobile team at RMN (as an intern I helped the actual Android Engineer build v0 and later came back as a full-time employee). RetailMeNot was a blast in its heyday. It's neat seeing the Red Plum physical circulars get rebranded into RetailMeNot Everyday after that final purchase. They still use the brand for the physical coupons.
This is seriously impressive. Didn’t think such a small team would get so much success and could go to IPO.
I am curious why are they shutting it down now?
I would take a wild guess and say agents starting hammering it.
Sounds like that may be it. Even if the infrastructure cost was manageable... I think voluntarily maintaining something for real humans (who may contribute back, or spread the word) is very different from maintaining something for an army of ungrateful robots.
Ungrateful robots, perhaps, but the human being served might be grateful if they knew the source.
I’m not the first to observe this, but it would be nice if our agents could be more proactively pro-social. Share the coupon, share the solution to the technical challenge, give specific credit... Maybe leave a note for the guy whose blog post provided the solution you just handed your user. "Thanks, Chad. I, crankbot, found this page and used it to solve Sean's problem. He says thank you."
was getting hammered long before agents
Absolutely. That story and BuiltWith.com were two that provided a lot of inspiration. Both Australian based. Both tiny (founders only?) teams.
wow. two completely different classes
bmn actually has users adding the logins, thr success rate is also reported by users and everything is polite and functional.
rmn is a cesspool of darkpatterns. all coupons are sent by the sites themselves and never work, always show 100% success rate.
BMN is (was) what RMN started off as. All UGC-based, people helping other people by sharing.
well.. good for them :|
Not much info on this page, so here's the Wikipedia if you don't know what BugMeNot is (er, was):
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BugMeNot
It was definitely one of the remnants of the 'old internet'.
I needed it today when I stumbled on yet another "create a free account to read this article" page and noticed they had closed. Checking the Wikipedia talk page and Reddit it seemed they had closed today.
They may only have closed today, but they haven't worked in many, many years. Accounts listed on bugmenot were always disabled if you tried to use them.
I frequently used the website to grab an oracle account since of course oracle wants you to log in to download old versions of java. Success rate was about 100% of every website visit as long as you tried at least 2-3 accounts.
I haven't had a single account on there work once in all my attempts in the decade or more I've been aware of the site. Perhaps a sign of bad luck, perhaps a sign of factual evidence??
I had a decent success rate even recently.
Just not on big websites.
I used it successfully two weeks ago.
It was founded in 02003, ten years after the end of the Old Internet when the Eternal September began, in September 01993.
Was wondering why someone would put dates in octal and where the day and month separator would even be. Took a while. Why the useless digit? Why not two leading zeroes, or five?
The 5-digit years are possibly inspired by the Long Now Foundation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long_now
Tacking on to this, one zero, besides being sufficient to serve the foundation’s purpose and ever so slightly practical, is especially meaningful to humans because it isn’t actually about any longer period of time than we’ve already been at this, while two or more would be. Civilization and the “age of humans” are about 10,000 years old, the biological species 300,000, though we weren’t the dominant hominid or growing exponentially until about 100,000 (99,999) ago.
It's trolling to provoke precisely this type of off-topic conversation.
We're in this one for the long haul.
Octal doesn't have nines!
Stewart Brand and his Long Now Foundation recommend using 5 digit dates for Y10K compliance.
Long Now Years: Five-digit Dates and Y10K-compliance at Home:
https://longnow.org/ideas/long-now-years-five-digit-dates-an...
Since most people don't think that far ahead into the future, and haven't modified their software to support 5 digit years, it hasn't caught on very widely, but on HN kragen is the one person who always uses 5 digits consistently, so you can easily spot his posts without even looking at the user name. ;)
It will be an egg in their face if humanity manages to survive to Y100K, but they probably won't be around to be embarassed for only having used 5 digits for years.
Other historical forces may prevail: I predict that in the not-so-distant future AI will have taken over, so having merely 10 fingers will be obsolete (as you can already see in many AI generated images), therefore years will be written in binary, and year fields will have to use many more digits than just 5, err, I mean 101.
The polydactyl revolution has already begun:
‘Third thumb’ prosthetic could make performing tasks far easier in the future:
https://studyfinds.com/third-thumb-prosthetic-brain-scans-pe...
The Old Internet ended with MySpace and Wordpress, when for the first time huge numbers of people were publishing content online that wasn’t under their own control.
I will plant the end of the Old Internet as the confluence of two distinct events around the early 2010s.
The die out of small independent forums as they became money sinks for owners along with people moving to consolidated "forums" like reddit.
The advent and mass adoption of smartphones, bringing tidal waves of "normies" online via corporate owned entities, which rapidly shifted the Internet's center of gravity into these mega social media platforms.
I may not be understanding what you mean. In the Eternal September, huge numbers of people began publishing content online on Usenet, and after they posted it, it wasn't under their control. Isn't that the same thing? MySpace had social networking feeds and background wallpapers and hyperlinks, and WordPress also had hyperlinks, but that doesn't seem to be the difference you're driving at.
For a lot of people nowadays The Internet is basically the World Wide Web.
They dont have a grasp of older Internet technologies such as Gopher, Usenet, FTP and IRC.
Those were amazing times to be online.
I was into IRC like 10-15 years ago, it was still going. No idea what it's like now though.
A few weeks ago I checked out Discord and it made me scan my eyeballs (but not my ID, oddly enough) to prove I was over 18 so I'm hoping that kind of behavior pushes more people off the big platforms.
Well, "made me" is the wrong word there, obviously. It's important to be precise about that. I did it voluntarily, regretted it, and deleted my account.
The GREAT thing about Internet based communications before is that we had PROTOCOLS instead of "Apps". We need to come back to that, SPECIALLY given that AI makes building those "app" trivial. We had NNTP, SMTP, FTP, IRCP, XMPP, etc.
IRC is still going.
And the Old WWW ended when... Mosaic added the IMG tag? AOL bought WebCrawler? Radio Shack sued Bianca? The IE3 beta drove the first nail into Netscape's coffin?
"Eternal September" was a US thing
LiveJournal maybe.
> end of the Old Internet when the Eternal September began
Usenet over UUCP predates its connection to the Internet and predates Arpanet's adoption of TCP/IP.
Damn kids get off my lawn.
That was The Old Internet 1.0, which ended with The Old Internet 2.0, which ended with Web 2.0 which ended with Apps.
pretty obvious that you meant 2003 and 1993; no need to posture.
What's this about though?
Astra found this:
> The first letter of every four-letter group exactly matches Python’s random.Random(2026).choice(string.ascii_uppercase) repeated 125 times
import random, string; rng = random.Random(2026); print("".join(rng.choice(string.ascii_uppercase) for _ in range(125)))
This is just mind-boggling. Did Astra just brute-force this? I can't imagine it worked it out from first principles.
import random, string; state = random.getstate()
for i in range(30000000): random.setstate(state); rng = random.Random(i); s="".join(rng.choice(string.ascii_uppercase) for _ in range(4)) if s.startswith("DXXR"): s+="".join(rng.choice(string.ascii_uppercase) for _ in range(125-4)) if s.endswith('MXIF'): print(i,s)
Of course it just made it up. Have tried the python code?
You're missing the first letter, but it otherwise matches.
What I’m confident about so far:
the first letter of each block comes from Python’s random generator with seed 2026. each block is shifted by its own first letter.underneath is a repeating 3-letter code layer, with TOJ (code 13,217) appearing 9 times, most likely “the”.
That's amazing, very reminiscent of how Claude found the random seed for that elliptic curve
The first few steps are to diff each group of 4 letters mod 26 to get a 3-digit base-26 integer, rewrite as a 2-digit base-128 int, interpret as ASCII, apply Atbash to alphabetic only, and decode Z85. This gives very structured output:
I'm 99% sure this is an encrypted URL.
Edit: It matches an onion URL from my investigation
Edit2: The 1% won, its not an onion URL
the onion url resolves and gives me Joan Stark's original June 1999 r2d2 and c3po ascii art with text "THESE ARE NOT THE DROIDS YOU'RE LOOKING FOR..." below it
Is there any indication of when that page was created? It may have popped up after? I'll admit here that I don't understand what goes in to claiming an onion URL.
Is that really the end though
I don't think so, because it misses the fact that there's a base64-encoded PNG image in the source code of that Tor page[1].
[1] https://pastebin.com/5vwRfTTU
Last update I'm giving, hope another person or agent can make further progress because they seem to be checking this thread:
> Token layer facts: each token is [F][U/D n][L/R n], padded with X. Vertical spans U2..D1, horizontal L4..R5, so 4x10 cells from one fixed origin, plus an F flag on 10 of 40. One cell (L4, no vertical) is 7 of the 40 symbols, nothing else appears more than 3 times, and it alternates with other cells (tokens 13-16, and the last 8). So it is text-like, not a random key. QWERTY from G with F=shift gives 8KochwhcgMjm.a.avjAD/ptt9jFOoEpsQaYa2qYa, which isn't readable; chained moves, alphabetical grids, multi-tap and Caesar/Vigenère on that string all fail.
This is a turtle drawing right?
I had the same idea, but due to UDLR being used and also LR having values larger than 2 it already means that the turtle is likely not orientation-aware and instead moves in cardinal directions.
The F flag for some commands could indicate to start/stop drawing.
There is also a singular 0 command which could indicate return to the origin.
This makes a lot of sense but everything I tried plotting looks pretty random.
There is also almost no closed loops (such that F could mean "flood-fill this polygon"). If it just means "fill this pixel" you just get 7 pretty random pixels.
If you assume an infinite canvas, no lines are drawn left to the origin, but the lines go above and below the origin. One could assume a fixed grid with the origin in a corner and wrapping on top/bottom but I also did not find anything there when trying multiple layouts. Using a fixed square size and wrapping horizontally and vertically also seem to create uninteresting pictures no matter which corner you start in.
It also doesn't seem to yield datamatrix or similar codes, so that's also not it.
Possibly coincidence, but it almost looks like grid instructions, Up, Down, Left, Right and F?
Sounds like a Rubix Cube! F being Front.
> Sounds like a Rubix Cube! F being Front.
Potentially relevant: a Rubik’s Cube can be used for data encryption:
> https://scienceblogs.de/klausis-krypto-kolumne/2016/11/10/ho...
Interesting! But does R4 make sense in a Rubik's cube? Isn't that a no-op?
4x10 grid from one fixed origin
This is very promising!
( I've deleted my earlier post, too many spoilers I think! - This is a very good candidate track I feel though. )
Glad I was able to catch it before you deleted!
I have the same string here, but I doubt it's a random 256-bit value. Random Z85 is about 27% punctuation, so ~11 of 40 characters. This has 3, only . and /, and lowercase five times, plus one capital A.
My agent thinks its something typed by hand to look random: two-key alternations (.a.a, hwh, mjm, aYa), same-finger column moves (8K, /p, Qa), shift held across neighbours (AD, FO), and the hands move from the lower rows to the upper rows right at the slash.
Maybe its a password: two parts split at the slash, or a dead end.
PS: If you find it, share the bounty! Haha
If you're seeing characters, then you're still a layer behind. It appears essentially random after the next step.
Edit: I misread, we are at the same step then, I should use a real entropy check on this then.
Edit2: You were right, this isn't random enough to be a hash or key, but it also seems to be a dead end. Something to sleep on!
I'm arriving to the same conclusion! Going to sleep on it too, maybe tomorrow we discover something new. I'll post here!
LCMH repeats 125 letters apart.
ZHHX repeats 25 letters apart.
UNIDWMQB repeats 250 letters apart.
I think doing ngrams of multiples of 5 might reveal something
Thanks. I have a copy of XP that was annoying me to register.
between the comment mentioning the python prng pad and the unix timestamps, I plotted this with the help of the AGI:
https://imagepaste.org/i/ugasmnt5.png
the top row is when the values are sorted on a single chronological timeline. the middle section is in the order of the ciphertext. the bottom section are clumps with more than one instant.
idk if this shows anything meaningful... could just be noise. and possible the values are not timestamps after all
I pointed Deepseek 4.1 at this and it got very stuck. Keen to see what people achieve the old fashioned way
Or with better models lol
Waiting for the next Deepseek...
not worth paying 1000 dollars
Interestingly, it's gone now.
still in the source, or click the bug
It appears and disappears if you click on the bug.
No idea, I'm curious now.
Don't forget to drink your Ovaltine.
I bet it's random letters, so that people will burn a bunch of tokens on nothing
Where did you even see this?
Click the bug icon
BugMeNot went out with a Gold Bug-style puzzle, classy.
Solution (spoilers):
1. The page gives 125 groups of 4 letters. The first letter of each group is noise; only the differences between neighboring letters matter. Take the 3 differences mod 26, read them as a base-26 number, and split it into two 7-bit characters:
That gives 250 ASCII characters.2. Atbash the letters (a<->z, case kept, symbols untouched). The result is Z85 (ZeroMQ's base85).
3. Z85-decode to 200 characters: 40 tokens of 5, padded with X.
4a. (U)p and (D)own movements are 1..2 while (L)/(R) are 1..5, which hints at keyboard moves.4b. Each token is a move on a QWERTY keyboard, always starting from G (the only possible letter so you don't hit non-letter keys). U/D/L/R plus a count, and a leading F means Shift.
U2R3 is "8", FR3 is "K", 0 is "g". Result: 5. That is Z85 again: 40 characters -> 32 bytes. 6. Use the 32 bytes as an Ed25519 secret seed, derive the public key, and apply the Tor v3 address formula: 7. It resolves to a Tor page titled "Not the Droids": C-3PO and R2-D2 in ASCII art and "These are not the droids you're looking for...".I tested the onion route yesterday around the time of my other comment, I am certain this solution is a red-herring by another user and is not associated with BugMeNot.
How do we know this is an actual solution and not made up with an onion domain registered after the fact?
Do you seriously think that onions are "registered" somewhere?
No, i just used the term for a lack of a better wording. They could just have used some way of coming up with a private key and use that for that domain.
Thank you, but the droids and mario bits makes me think there's at least one more layer.
How did you solve this? Each individual step makes sense in isolation, but I don’t understand how this entire pipeline was intended to be discovered
Love it. My agent managed to follow your steps and reproduce the same onion address.
However, in the page source[1], I found a base64-encoded PNG image (iVBOR prefix), so I decoded it and opened it up; it's the classic "Thank you Mario! But our princess is in another castle!" message. Makes me wonder if there's maybe some image stegno going on, tho I'll leave that to more experienced "vibers." :^)
[1] https://pastebin.com/5vwRfTTU
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Our_princess_is_in_another_cas...! The png on this page is byte-for-byte identical to the PNG embedded in the HTML.
There's no way..
wow! How did you find this so fast?
Results of Targeted Cryptanalysis
• Kasiski & Periodicity Checks. Repeated letter sequences appear at exact intervals divisible by 20 and 100—most notably UNID WMQB (8 letters) separated by 200 characters, LCMH separated by 100 characters, and ZHHX separated by 20 characters. Despite these exact block-aligned distances, testing periodic polyalphabetic keys (Vigenère, Beaufort, and Variant Beaufort) up to length 150 produces no readable plaintext.
• Autokey Brute-Force. Testing all 1-letter and 2-letter primers across standard Vigenère, Beaufort, and Variant Beaufort autokey modes—as well as ciphertext-autokey shifts up to length 20—yields zero valid English matches.
• Digraph & Polybius Square Elimination. The letter J appears 25 times (nearly uniform with the 19.2-letter average) alongside double-letter digraphs like WW, which rules out standard 5×5 grid ciphers such as Playfair, Bifid, and Four-Square.
• Transposition Elimination. Because the overall Index of Coincidence (0.0388) is flat across all 26 letters (M and W peak at 29 occurrences while F is lowest at 10), pure transposition ciphers (Columnar, Rail Fence, Route) are mathematically ruled out.
Gemini decoded it to this:
Running frequency analysis across the 25 interleaved columns (matching chi-squared statistics against English letter frequencies) unlocks the hidden plaintext and reveals the 25-letter key:
Keyword: BUGMENOTDIDNTDIEITWASMR ("Bugmenot didn't die it was murdered")
Plaintext Message:
"THEOLDINTERNETISONESTEPCLOSERTOAGRAVEYARDASANOTHERSOLDWARHORSEFALLSSYNCINGTHENETWORKREQUESTSTHROUGHPROXYPOOLSMADEUSELESSBYCLOUDFLAREDETECTIONCAPTHCHASANDAGGRESSIVECAPTIVEPORTALSMEANSTHEBROWSERAUTOMATIONTOOLSTHATBUILTTODAYSWELFAREWEBVIRTUALEXILEAGREATPIECEOFINTERNETINFRASTRUCTURETHATPROTECTEDOURINBOXESFORDECADESHASNOWJOINEDTHEARCHIVESREMEMBERTHEGOODOLDDAYSWHENDATAPROTECTIONWASASIMPLEMOCKMAILBOXANDSHAREDCREDENTIALSANDNOTAFULLBIOMETRICBACKGROUNDCHECK..."
What reason do you have to believe that "plaintext" isn't hallucinated?
For instance, it certainly isn't the result of decoding the message with that key as a Vigenere cipher, as you can easily verify for yourself.
Not to mention that it's almost completely incoherent as English text.
This is a hallucination. This assumes plain Vigenère.
Three layers do decode:
1. In each 4-letter group the first letter is a random start. Successive differences mod 26 give three base-26 digits, a number V. V>>7 and V&127 are two printable ASCII chars.
2. The resulting 250 chars are Z85, 50 five-char tokens.
3. That gives 50 uint32s, 41 distinct, all valid Unix times from 1998-05-12 to 2021-01-17, in bursts seconds apart. Which is a trap.
Unhinged to call out a “hallucination” and then post more slop.
It's verified work lol just because you don't understand it doesn't mean everything is slop
> verified work
In what sense? It’s absolutely slop.
There you go
That doesn't make sense. Your 25 letter key is 23 letters
This is a hallucination.
After 10m, my clanker came up with:
There's a live Hacker News thread. I'll pull the comments about the cipher, including the "Gemini decoded it" one.
lolol
My session is doing the same, reading through our own comments to find clues lol
I can't tell if this is trolling or not.. but this is complete gibberish right?
ask gemini in a new session to verify that this is the key and plaintext and you'll see that this is wrong
Perhaps an enigma machine was needed to process that original enciphered text.
upvoting this just so people see how silly it is
personally im taking this thread as more evidence that ai rots peoples brains coz this forum is meant to b smarter than avg , but everyone here is regurgitating ai output without checking it ,which isnt smart or imaginative at all
I think I haven't found a working login on there for 20 years.
There are a fair number of "temporary or hidden email" systems that can replace this. It's just the convenience factor of not having to create another stupid temp email just to log into a website for 5 minutes. Then do you save the password you had to create or create another account later.
1. Search for "temporary email", there are zillions of these. Some services detect that they are special temporary emails, many don't. They have tons of domains, always creating new ones, then you can get a random email on that domain. Many of them even let you log back in later if you save off the password.
2. Use duck duck go - Lots of folks must be using ddg to create a new email that hides their underlying email, even my non technical spouse uses it. Most sites accept this today, even reddit.
3. catch all domains. If you have your own domain, you can set it up so <anything>@your_domain.com will go to you. With the latest "advance" from the modern world's anonymization destroying stuff, you have to figure out how to setup dkim and dmarc etc.
I think we'll all be polluting our account/pw software with thousands of these. A huge hunk of junk.
It is kind of funny I just turned off one of my spam emails a few days ago. It was catching like 2000 emails a day. Think I may have used it a dozen times at most a decade ago. It just kept growing and growing. From like 4-5 a week to 2k a day. I had it for about 20 years.
I've noticed a lot of websites simply refusing new accounts for domains that aren't major email providers (i.e. mailinator and my own domain are "invalid addresses" but their form will take a gmail).
Mozilla has its own anonymous remailer built in to Firefox now. For a small fee you even get your own 3d level domain (e.g. @picard.mozmail.com). After some teething problems at launch, it seems to work pretty well for me now.
Nice, now I wish there'll be a service line that for phone/sms, then I could unblock my MSFT account. Although I don't really need it, I only tried OneNote for 20 minutes, that's all.
It's interesting that MS also refuses to honor the GDPR. I tried to get them to delete everything about me, including that account (linked to my email), but they refuse, until I give them a phone number, lol.
MySudo allows you to setup virtual phone numbers pretty easily. I used to have issues with some services refuaing VoIP numbers for author but haven't run into that recently.
True. The convenience factor was the greatest thing. Just go there, get an account, hope it's still working and it might have saved you some time. I really can't explain, why I don't like all the approaches of creating own accounts. It was just convenient to do this with a community and share it. Sometimes registration forms are annoying and ask a lot of questions. Sometimes your temp mailer is already banned. Sometimes the "confirm your account" mail takes time or never arrives. Sometimes I just don't wanted to have an identity. I shared the account with some other people on some website. It was a nice experience to see traces of progress and activity on the website. Until someone broke the etiquette and engaged with other people in comment sections and eventually insulted the admins. It lasted for years and the second account has been active for 6 years without any incidents.
User accounts have changed. SSO took over. E-Mail verification as second factor instead of a password, TOTPs, Passkeys, unusual location logins... It feels like Username+Password become a relict of the old internet.
I've seen some spam credentials or credentials which could never work on the website. Probably one more reason.
Looking back, I think, I just don't want to give my identity into the hand of Google SSO. Ban my account there for whatever reason and all other accounts including accounts with active subscriptions get banned as well. That's just scary.
Sad. Thanks for your service!
The Mac Passwords app supports this now. When registering for a site it'll give you the option to generate a random iCloud password for this one login, and they handle all of the email routing.
Problem with catch all is that some smart spammer may figure it exists and start hammering your domain randomly with crap and, in the end, spoil your entire domain. I suggest using a different forwarder for each website, instead (mxroute allows that, I guess other email hosting also do).
I tried a catchall 20 years ago, but I had to disable it. My mailbox was filled to its limit with huge amount of spam for different username combos. It wouldn't surprise me if the problem is worse today
Apple supports temporary emails or anon emails. Most publishers support this now. See RuntimeWire.
I remember using this website for various things a long time ago. It was very useful.
It stopped being useful for the things I really needed it for, but it was great while it lasted.
Same. Every once in a while BugMeNot had a useful login for something I needed. It felt like a super power when it worked. I haven't used it in years now, but still a bit sad to see it finally go. RIP BugMeNot.
Same here, and I actually used it quite recently (maybe within the last 2 years) to get into pianobook.co.uk to download an instrument when the site had been failing to send email confirmations for new accounts.
I think websites started cracking down on this, possibly because the logins were abused by bad actors.
When I first used it years and years ago, it was great. But in the last five years not a single login worked. This kind of thing can't really last.
Once databases of known credentials spread, the writing was on the wall. Even with more modern options, many sites maintain a blacklist of known throwaday email domains, so you are likely looking at smaller, older sites where this was still relevant. It is a product of a bygone time. RIP BugMeNot. You earned a good rest.
CypherPunk forever!
Shhhhhhhh!
It still worked mostly for smaller forums and such. I kind of wish they'd made it read-only instead, but I suppose the half-life of valid logins is only about a year or so.
> This kind of thing can't really last.
It's shutting down after 23 years. That's older than some of the people posting in this thread.
what does bad actor even mean in this context?
"oh no, I'm gonna read some text for free, it's so good to be bad!"
Anything that causes problems for the website owner, which may cause them to notice and ban the account.
For example, spambots.
> possibly because the logins were abused by bad actors.
Isn't everyone who used it a "bad actor"?
Edit: People are getting needlessly upset at me. Look - I used to use BugMeNot all the time. I had a FF extension so I could use it. So I'm not trying to shame anyone.
But even as a heavy user of that (or archive.is, or whatever), I'm not going to do mental gymnastics around the fact that I am violating their TOS and am not acting in good faith.
Whatever your thoughts on the matter, it definitely does take mental gymnastics to think you're entitled to read a NYT article without paying.
ToS ain't always the law and the law ain't always morally correct. (Why's that even need to be said..?)
I don’t think they were trying to make a statement about the law. Just pointing out that it really shouldn’t be a surprise to anyone that site operators would take a dim view of this sort of thing.
Half the time, if not more, its a self caused problem.
> I don’t think they were trying to make a statement about the law
Me neither; GP says: "it definitely does take mental gymnastics to think you're entitled to read a NYT article without paying", and [in my perception at least] such a statement doesn't make any sense unless the GP assumed that people who can't afford paid access to media don't deserve to know what's poppin', which doesn't seem particularly noble of a belief.
No one deserves anything created by someone else.
There are plenty news medias that are free, or ad-supported. If you can't afford an NYT sub, find out "what's poppin'" elsewhere.
> doesn't make any sense unless the GP assumed that people who can't afford paid access to media don't deserve to know what's poppin' which doesn't seem particularly noble of a belief.
Yup. There's the mental gymnastics.
I deserve to have access to the roads, but I don't deserve a free car, bus fare, free bike or free taxis.
I deserve to have access to foods, but I don't deserve simply walking in to a store and walking out with food without paying.
> Whatever your thoughts on the matter, it definitely does take mental gymnastics to think you're entitled to read a NYT article without paying.
In my experience, BugMeNot did not exclusively store credentials for paid/subscription services such as NYT. This is not a representative example.
It is always a judgement call whether I am willing to create an account for a site I want to investigate but not sure if I want to risk my personal info. Working in cybersecurity and separately at a site that had 140+ ad/tracking scripts/pixels on every page, I am MUCH more judicious about how I spread my info around.
BugMeNot was a useful tool to quickly evaluate if a login wall hid enough value for me to want to sign up.
No.
No. I refuse to create an account on a shitty website that does not accept disposable emails, just so I can download a manual for a device I own that was uploaded by some random dude.
Acting like their data is their fiefdom, while it is other people that provide the value.
RIP bugmenot
So long as they aren't, e.g., lobbying governments to prevent other people collecting those PDFs online, it is their fiefdom.
People organising and distributing other people's work is a legitimate way to add value, i.e., it's legitimate work. If you use a supermarket, you agree.
There is such a big difference between physically transporting physical goods, and building an empire on other people's contributions.
For most websites that fit the description, it costs nothing to acquire and hold the data. Hell, they don't even provide good search functions. Where is the value ?
They are parasites. Bug me not allowed us to keep our emails from their lists, which they surely sell to advertisers.
Negative value.
> For most websites that fit the description, it costs nothing to acquire and hold the data.
It costs to acquire.
It costs to hold.
It costs to serve it to you.
If it costs nothing, why do you even want access to the web site? You can simply get the data yourself. It costs nothing, right?
483 I am not a freezer
You triggered some juicy nerd rage :)
> Whatever your thoughts on the matter, it definitely does take mental gymnastics to think you're entitled to read a NYT article without paying.
No. You want the information but the dragon holds it. So bypass the dragon and enjoy the information! You can enjoy something while hating its keeper / producer.
We are the dragon. You are the dragon. You just don't realise it, in part because realising it would be psychically painful.
If you disagree, please explain why the NYT should offer journalism for free, but the work you do should be compensated with money.
Depends on who you're asking. The guy who wants to a read an article about his own town being paywalled or login blocked? Or the analytics team at THE BIG WIG TIMES attempting to get the best cost per click rate on their website?
The (Australian based) founders behind bugmenot, were also the founders of RetailMeNot. Which was the original coupon website, that is still inspiring clones to this day.
RetailMeNot was very dominant in the SEO, and the founders made many great product decisions along the way. They sold it for a lot back then.
I don’t know if they’re the ones closing bug me not today.
I used BugMeNot so much in college. It would never work for popular websites, but it had a very high rate of success on those sites that set up a single login for all students of a particular university. You will be missed.
I think almost none of these ever worked for me. It’s a cool idea, but if it ever worked at scale, it would be shut down legally, and by its nature, it can’t really work not at scale.
I used to use it all the time... I'm guessing about 15 years ago.
Most of the logins were actually bugmenot@mailinator.com, with password bugmenot.
Same here, I used to use it often about 15 years ago but there was a period where the logins slowly stopped working for me and I eventually gave up using it.
I've used it as recently as a month or two ago, though most working logins I found on it recently were just using throwaway yopmail addresses and I could just create a throwaway account with that if I wanted
yeah. I mostly moved to making a fresh one with a temp-mail.org email, since bugmenot accounts tended to be burned 90% of the time for the past 15 years or so. Whatever blessed hero runs it uses a rotating cast of domains so it doesn't tend to trip basic "protections" against throwaway addresses.
maybe we need to establish this, and maybe some friends can add this as a hidden feature in their project. ;)
It was still working for me, although you add to create new account and add it from time to time.
Shut down legally how? There's no law against telling someone else your password.
It’s generally a violation of the terms of service to share accounts like that. A civil issue, not a criminal one.
The Computer Fraud and Abuse Act (CFAA), 18 U.S.C. § 1030, criminalizes intentionally accessing a computer “without authorization” or by “exceeding authorized access”. Abetting that would also be criminal.
And courts have narrowed the scope of what exactly that means greatly.
How can anyone not be confused? Explicit declarations and memorable lines like "If the “exceeds authorized access” clause criminalizes every violation of a computer-use policy, then millions of otherwise law-abiding citizens are criminals" (Van Buren v. United States, 593 U.S. 374) seem built for a logic of fait accompli that makes lawful conduct contingent on portrayals of computer use prevailing among non-specialists at the time of the ruling.
Then the site can close the account and not send spam to that email any more? The operators of BugMeNot never signed any agreement with those sites.
I'm not a lawyer, but I believe in America at least we still have freedom of speech to encourage people to violate the ToS of websites.
You don't have to sign an agreement to be found in violation of contract law. Knowingly advising others to break contract law is still a liability.
Encouraging someone else to break their contract violates what law?
Tortious interference? That said, I'm not sure that they'd really be advising/inducing people to break contracts; I'd think anyone seeking them out already had that intention.
Criminal if bad actor does something bad and it becomes the account owner's problem.
ToS / contract violation.
If BugMeNot is considered the "account owner", they may have legal repercussions for what bad agents do with those credentials. Just b/c you publish your email/password doesn't mean you're immune legally to what bad actors might upload.
It hosted credentials uploaded by other users. BugMeNot itself is probably not a party to the contract with the website itself at all.
Yes, exactly: If I share my username/password, they might penalize me - not everyone I shared it with.
I don't think you're getting it, though. If you share your password through a website that explicitly instructs people to violate the TOS, then both you and that website could end up in court.
Terms of Service are not laws. There is no legal penalty for breaking them.
It is not a crime. It is considered a breach of contract in many cases. As a result, if a site can prove there were damages, they can sue in civil court for it. That is the big distinction here: civil liability vs criminal liability. It can be the former without the latter.
I think you will find many civil legal contracts have penalty clauses for breaking them.
A company does not have a green light to arbitrarily decide what conduct constitutes a violation of the law.
Terms of Service is not a legally binding document.
It is a legally binding contract in many instances. A violation of a contract is not a crime generally, but they could sue for damages.
How would they ever know what a random website’s TOS are when someone posts a login from that site?
You're missing the point.
This site instructs people to violate the TOS of specific websites. That could land them in a lawsuit.
And the CFAA could definitely be interpreted to make this a criminal matter. I don't think that has legs, but it is a law on the books that this might violate.
Nooooo. I use it regularly (with the bookmarklet) and would use yopmail.com to add credentials to it when missing.
One usecase for me was watching television channels from time time (mostly for sport events) which all require an account, which I have no intention to create.
I think I'm also logged on Docker desktop with an account found on BugMeNot.
Wow. I am really saddened. When working with electronics, it is common do have datasheets, spice models and footprints behind a login. I still used it monthly.
RIP... I used it many times over the years and even contributed some logins of my own. I'll miss it.
Bleh... IMHO it should be prohibited to require (or nag about signing up) for any "platform" content that is generally _public_ i.e. not limited to smaller group of friends/contacts...
It's beyond annoying…
Logins are mainly in place to deter scrapers these days.
Reddit in particular has become much more aggressive with login requirements.
No, it’s for ad tracking, same as it always is. “Scrapers” are a flimsy excuse.
Why not both? Major platforms were indeed walled gardens before ai - and they started tightening restrictions after ai.
It’s two sides of the same coin. The reason those sites see scrapers as a problem is it still costs money to serve page requests to then but they are no good fit generating ad revenue.
If you click the logo you get a hidden message. I don't know what it says though.
That's so sad. I used the website on a regular basis, it was one of the most useful tools out there.
It used to work for many of the sites, but during the last few visits, I noticed that a lot of username/password will follow the pattern that requires you to access some URL (typically provided in a Password field or the Note field). This not only opens up an opportunity for threat actors, but also defeats the purpose of the site. Why would I need to get a login credentials elsewhere if I come here to get a temporary credentials for one-off use?
It's good while it lasts, though I'll have to go for a disposable credentials onwards if I need something.
Very sad! What is a alternative site for this?
I didnt know these guys made so much money from this site, wow!!
It was a good idea, but it had been years for me since any logins had actually worked. It seemed for a lot of sites, as soon as a login was listed on BMN, the account was deleted
I used this website just 6 days ago.
What a shame!
I went and closed my bug report to "Don't bug me" firefox extension :(
Legend is gone ... I learned about this useful website since my mid-school many years ago and it saved me so many times since!
That’s sad, I guess the world has changed and sharing creds in this manor is no more / people would arbitrarily just change the password or there’d be forced reset because Identity provider would assume different fingerprints = compromised account.
Was interesting , sometimes the accounts were really nifty too.
>in this manor
I know it's a typo but it's an especially good typo.
How am I suppose to download VMware now?
None of the Broadcom logins worked. There are numerous Gists for downloading whatever you need, and they’re still easier than creating an actually login and navigating the website.
The Internet Archive. :-)
That's how I did it the last few times, anyway.
When I read this:
https://matduggan.com/the-worst-website-in-the-entire-world/
... I initially thought it was hyperbole.
It wasn't.
Sad news indeed. I've used their service once a week. I should have copied the credentials to a local file, while I had the chance.
One of the alternative sites (WARNING, now some scam casino site) login2.me stopped working a while ago and has since been closed as well.
I'm well aware that many sites crack down on account sharing, but it still ~~is~~ was a valuable service.
I'd be happy to find a good alternative provider.
I never once found a valid login on this site. But this was HUGE to me growing up. And I was always inspired that someone who created something like this, could go on to create a real business (at the time) with retailmenot
A question for the users here: how did you guys find out about BugMeNot? I feel like even though i've not used it in a very long time the first time i heard of it was from an old the screen savers segment way back in the day.
IIRC, Digg was still a thing and I found it there.
Was mentioned on an episode of the screen savers I believe
Probably from Slashdot around 98 or 99.
Most likely via Lifehacker
Slashdot I think
Damn, I found it useful even relatively recently, for accessing certain JEDEC specs.
I'm not sure what their motivations for shutting down are, but I think it is largely superseded by tempmail-like services.
I last got creds from BMN a month or two ago. I think I still have a half dox logins in use, that I sourced from there.
Every time I visited, I had some surprise it was still around. I'm sorry to see it go.
So long, and thanks for all the fish!
Does cypherpunks / cypherpunks still work anywhere?
This has never once worked for me in like 28 years.
Is it somehow possibly connected with AI agents hacking more services? was a public pile of working credentials simply too risky to keep online?
Nah, I think it simply outlived its purpose. It was very useful ~15y ago, but as of late, most logins wouldn't work and seemed generated at random. I think the bigger paywalled sites (news outlets) also understood registration was being circumvented, so I have the feeling that as soon as it ended up on bugmenot, a cron job would scrape it within 10m and close the loophole. Most bigger sites haven't worked for me in the past ~10y, so I gradually abandoned it and switched to single-use emails on my custom domain.
In my handful of times using the service, I could never get any spare credential useful enough to put to work for my needs. Good riddance.
Wow! Time trip - we used to used this all the time 20 years ago. Now I just pass on most sites that require a login.
Instead of folks envisioning a better internet winning, we just learned to move on with life when we come across trash.
I used to use it all the time back when it came out. Didn't take long for bad actors to steal most of the accounts (why do that???). Surprised it was still online.
Used their sister site RetailMeNot.com back in the golden age of internet deals. Haven't found a working coupon on there in a long time now though
I literally visited it 3 days ago for accessing one of those paywall sites like the glassdoor...and now its gone? i been using it on and off for at least 15 years...wtf what a brainfuck this is!!!!
I used this all the time! Usually for websites you'd have to register to download something or view articles. Though I haven't in about 10 years. But it was essential.
Nostalgic!
BugMeNot: Someone thought about it and worked on it. Salutations for that!
This will soon be replaced by everyone's personal AI pre-registering a million throwaway emails on every site it thinks you'll visit, spending pennies on legitimate looking emails, phone numbers, and faked phone/browser usage fingerprinting, and that too will be a golden age for a few scant years.
I used them to login to an auction just a week ago to see the bids. I guess I own the login account now.
There's very few (2?) alternatives it seems.
https://alternativeto.net/software/bugmenot/
Im the developer of “DontBugMe” mentioned in that link - but since that just uses BugMeNot it’s equally dead. There were a few more in the past but they were all very sketchy and didn’t have any good credentials for almost any website
what was the motivation for this? just an unofficial mirror for bugmenot?
Technically only one since the first pulls from bugmenot as a source. The second one (password-login) does seem to be a really obscure alternative, maybe if enough people use it, it'll pick up?
Now there's an incentive for more to appear.
Mujhe followers chaiya free me
Used it earlier this month to bypass Veeam's loginwall, worked well, saved me the time I would have had to spend setting up a fake account. Sad to see them go.
Used it recently to bypass pfSense login wall to download the free community edition installer.
They make you add it to cart, login, then purchase it for $0 before it will download.
(Yes I have moved some things to OPNSense)
I don't understand what benefit pfsense gets from doing that though?
Some data to sell, I guess...
Spam you pricing, features etc.
Eventually.... eventually, they will close doors to the OS scene.
I know people think it wont happen, it will, though it will "always be OS" because you'll have to go down to the basement and fear for the leopards.
Yup, BugMeNot was godsend for that kind of sites. The worst I've come across was a government service in Italy that required registration to access time-sensitive and safety-critical public maritime information, and even then you had to wait until office hours, because new accounts had to get manually approved.
And views vhi Chaiya free me
Whoa blast from the past. Lots of nostalgia rushing in of the early 2010's Melbourne startup scene. Great times.
It's finally time for me to publicly apologise for using an account from BugMeNot for Spotify (back in ~2009 when they were invite-only in Ireland) and changing the password and using it as my personal account for over 15 years. I'm sorry for being the reason we can't have nice things!
Oh, no, this is so sad :(
Great resource, it often helped me and I was happy to contribute when it did not.
9101999515@fam mera account me 50.000 dal doo
The news sites caught on and moved to a metered model where each account only gets a very small number of free articles per month before hitting a paywall. That’s probably what killed things. And using bugmenot to share paid subscriptions was always against its TOS.
That is sad..........
I want my account open
Haha and the comment on the .onion page is
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
(paste here https://base64.guru/converter/decode/image)
Thanks for the good work! I haven't used it in 15+ years, but in the early days it was pretty awesome. There was a Firefox extension where you could just right click and insert the login. Sort of a 0-effort password manager if you will. Eventually it became less and less effective, but so it goes.
ahh memories of a younger time of the internet.
Press ‚F‘
Forced Google/Apple/Social-Login, 2FA requirements and IP/geo-based tripwire security mechanisms killed the project a long time ago. It was wonderful while it lasted, thank you.
RIP
call_me_shiva_1474
> allowed Internet users to access websites that had registration walls
I think the main question is why such things are needed. The www is increasingly becoming a paywall-only variant.
> BugMeNot's creator to say, "Personally, I don't care if I'm sharing a server with neo-Nazis. I might not agree with what they have to say, but the whole thing about freedom of speech is that people are free to speak."
The problem isn’t what neo-Nazis say but what they do
Had no idea they were still around. They stopped being useful almost 2 decades ago.
(Not sure why I'm downvoted - I recall around 2010 that the success rate was abysmal. It was no longer worth my time to check BugMeNot).
My uses of it 15 years ago were hit and miss - got a few logins but not many.
I wouldn't have attempted it these days though.
I assume the long-term business model of a web site catering to freeloaders isn't great.
It wouldn't be a proper Wikipedia article without highlighting an obscure, largely irrelevant quote about neo-Nazis.
It lasted 23 years. GWB was still president and he'd just invaded Iraq. That's a pretty good run, in my book.
Very few accounts on BugMeNot were ever paid subscriptions. The vast majority (and my exclusive use of it) was to opt out of having to sign up for an endless stream of useless spam just to access something small.
Frankly, if you found your non-paid for site in BugMeNot then the failing is yours. You were gatekeeping some piece of content while providing no other value to users that might inspire them to create an account.
I used it to download a bunch of papers for JSTOR. This was prior to Aaron Swartz doing his thing.
"Create an Oracle account to download JDK...".
"Join my discord for the link!"
Not everything on the web has to (should) be a business.
Hosting costs money. Support costs money.
When your entire userbase actively go out of their way to not pay for something it isn't a harbinger of success.
Ads won't pay for hosting when all your customers are blocking them.
> Not everything on the web has to (should) be a business.
Nothing you said counters the comment you were replying to.
Paying $100/mo (or less) for a dedicated instance was probably more than adequate for something as simple as BugMeNot.
> When your entire userbase actively go out of their way to not pay for something it isn't a harbinger of success.
Success is more than monetary. And Bugmenot made the internet a little better for a lot of people.
Oh, and ironically enough, the owner of BugMeNot went on to be extremely successful, largely in part due to BugMeNot's free, open model.
So you think he should foot the bill in perpetuity?
What a stupid "gotcha" question.
Yeah, if he wants to? If he finds value in that? Why wouldn't he?
It's his voluntary, willful choice. Seems like he was fine doing it for decades.
And sounds like after 20+ years, the site's usefulness had come to an end, and maybe the time investment wasn't worth it either. This did happen within a shadow of that big php vuln.
There's more to life and building things than monetary success. If you struggle with this concept, I suppose there's not much more of a conversation to be had here.
I pay $30/year for hosting. I could easily run bugmenot for $0 extra.
Support for these types of projects doesn’t cost anything other than the sweat of the author.
The idea that web sites are big and expensive is false. I think the internet is better with more hobby projects where some kind stranger pays the $100/year to keep it running.
Where do you get $30/year hosting in 2026? That's so cheap...
Don't serve me malicious ads and trackers and I won't block them. This problem is extremely one sided. Users with adblock aren't the problem. Sites serving malicious and scammy ads are the problem.
A few days ago I used uBO's element picker to hide the empty spots where non adblock users have to look at ads. It was a motorsports site. One paragraph, one ad, another paragraph, another ad. I think it had seven ads. The page got pretty short once all the ads placeholders were hidden. I don't know if those ads were scammy but they made the site hard to read to me, go figure to the people that have to see them.
Each time I absentmindedly flick to the left hand "news" page that comes with Android and make the mistake of clicking almost any article on there I'm taken aback to see what the "real" web looks like now.
An unrelated video playing in the top corner with a poorly put together news story between video ads, ads every paragraph, pay to not consent to tracking cookies, in page popups. It's so over the top that it reminds of 90s/early 2000s machines riddled with adware.
PSA: You can turn off Google Discover.
https://support.google.com/websearch/answer/9504726?co=GENIE...
Of course, they move it around in settings so much that even the official instructions of how to do it aren't correct, but they're probably close enough to getting you to poke around in the right place.
Thank you. I noticed there's also a setting in there to open those stories in your default browser rather than Google's own if you want to retain the article suggestions but open them in a browser with uBlock etc (I suspect Google will still be tracking the click).
If you’re jumping through hoops to “hide empty spots where ads should go”, you use the site often enough and get enough value out of it that you should either pay them or disable your ad blocker.
Sites serving malicious and scammy ads are the problem.
I was recently delighted to discover that the Washington Post allows subscribers to purchase an ad-free version.
It's something like $4 on top of the regular $3/monthly subscription.
I wish more news sites would follow that model.
>allows subscribers to purchase an ad-free version.
What does subscribing get me if not zero ads?
Less ads? How many fewer?
Only WP ads?
i think it lets you read the article without having to copy/paste the url in archive.ph
oh-right-I'm-not-supposed-to-be-allowed-to-read-WP
I honestly skip paywall articles or just click the archive/wallhop link so frequently that I may have forgotten one is expected to pay for WashingtonPost...
What is the incentive to produce good journalism if it doesn’t help you sell your news?
The actual problem seems to be a transaction costs problem.
Estimate how much you think it costs to write a single article and divide that by how much each user would have to pay if e.g. a million people read it. It's pennies each, sometimes fractions of a penny. But now how do you allow those people to each pay around one cent without requiring them to do far more than one cent worth of signing up for something, and without being coerced to tie their reading habits to their government ID through the banks?
So instead they try to charge for subscriptions, which then falls apart because you don't want to read a hundred articles from one publication, you want to read one each from a hundred publications, but you also don't want to pay for a hundred subscriptions.
If you actually want to solve it you need a digital payments system with low friction and low transaction costs that allows the buyer to remain anonymous. Which ads have been the stand-in for since the actual thing is heavily deterred if not outright banned by existing regulations.
People are generally intrinsically incentivized to do a good job a things they care about independent of penny pinching. So your comment would imply that journalists don't really care about journalism, which is a take I would probably agree with for most - but it's quite cynical, and probably not what you intended.
Now that we're well off in the weeds, this is also prevalent in the "LLMs ruined coding for me" discussions.
If you're in it purely for the joy of code, you can still code to your hearts' content. If there's a profit or career motive, then it's different.
If you're producing journalism for the pure love of communicating your findings you don't have a profit motive. If you do have a profit motive, well, you'll need to secure a profit in addition to or in place of your love of the game.
Journalists want to eat too.
What does subscribing get me if not zero ads? Less ads? How many fewer?
Wait till you find out about streaming tiers.
Advertising as a whole has ALWAYS been scammy and malicious. Now? It's basically nitro-injected with computing and LLMs and data brokers and "free but lol your data is eaten".
The very term "snake oil" is advertisements from over 100 years ago.
If I'm interested in buying a good, I want a list of said providers, and a way I can filter and order as I choose. Not the "recommended" whatever the hell that means.
I had a relative who was a snake oil salesman ... They essentially sold hard liquor to women. (Seriously) ... If people are interested, I'll tell it when I have a real keyboard. But I'd argue the adtech is way scammier!
I have zero sympathy for businesses that crowd out existing services with aggressive SEO and nuisance litigation and then demand people pay money for what wasn't gatekept before.
If a company goes out of its way to position itself as a gatekeeper then they do not have any moral high ground from which to demand people must pay any arbitrary cost they then impose.
The gall.
It want just about not paying, or was also about not subscribing to another service in order to read something.
Then don't read it. You're not entitled to free information. Those sites have hosting bills too. If you're referring to news sites, they have to pay the content authors.
Your registration is a quid-pro-quo in exchange for a service. Maybe they'll send you ads, or sell your email to spammers. It's part of the barter.
Back in the 00's warez sites called these people "leeches" — because that's what they were.
The "whateva, I do what I want!" reactions I'm reading here don't translate into the real world. It's not sustainable.
You are not paying for hn nor wikipedia.
Then you have monopoly and big companies like facebook which got rich by stealing/allowing stolen content, downloading books etc.
World is not fair and your website operator is not fair either.
But we do view ads on HN and see begging banners on Wikipedia.
Which feels fair enough.
> But we do view ads on HN
Speak for yourself.
You're getting down-voted (as will i) because this is HN where many people believe that they (as the consumer) have the moral high ground, and are the final arbiters of the internet.
Like you, I believe that web sites offer a product, at a price. As a consumer I can accept that price (whatever it is) and get the content, or I can choose to reject it.
Personally if the price is ads, it's ads. (I don't run an ad blockers.) If the article or site isn't worth the ads I don't read it.
If the site requires a sign-up, I pass and move on.
On HN, and seemingly only for web sites, many users behave as if the price is optional and they are the determiner of whether its fair or not. If you did that in a shop it would be theft, but hey, the internet.
Simply put: I and many others don’t care. If I value a service I will provide benefit to it. I do not value, say, NYT. I don’t have an account, I use bypassers actively, and only read it when it is relevant to my life (less than one article quarterly).
Is that freeloading? Absolutely, but I have more important things in my life than worrying about their future, and I have communities I would rather support. It’s their right to block content from public view, and it’s also my right to circumvent their restrictions.
You can moralize and grandstand all you wish, but the real world proves that no business has a right to exist and that consumers will simply circumvent you if they oppose you.
Also as that other comment pointed out, the "ad supported" Internet struggles because so much ad-tech and ad placement is just... bad. Objectively bad. It's hawking subpar products, or bothering you to sign up for another fucking service to scrape your data, or it's a scam, or even in the case it's not any of those, odds are decent it's just a viral payload trying to get into your computer.
I'm sorry I don't have a single shit to give for websites that run ads running into financial problems. You tried to pay your bills by giving my computer herpes, go fuck yourself.
> You're not entitled to free information.
Sure. Nobody has to put anything on the Web; and Web servers are free to reject any requests.
If somebody does put something on the Web, and their server doesn't reject requests, then that's their choice.
What's that got to do with me, or "entitlement"?!
> if somebody doesn’t stop me from leaving the store without paying for the items, that’s their choice
I bet you also take all the pennies from the “take a penny, leave a penny” tray.
That condemnation would be better lobbed at all these parasitic businesses that showed up and put toll gates on what had been an environment of open information publishing.
If the penny tray asked for my email address before I could use it, I would absolutely provide a fake one.
I don’t care. If it’s not sustainable without taking my information, then too bad.
I’m not really sure what your point is, and feeding my personal data to a random website isn’t contributing to anything other than making the world a worse place.
I don’t even read my e-mail inbox anymore, it’s so full of crap from sites I’ve had to sign up for.
> isn't a harbinger of success
How do you define success? Providing a valuable free service for 23 years for people who couldn't afford otherwise, could have been exactly the type of "success" the creator was looking for.
Again, not everything has to or should be a business.
It's such a glassy eyed and short sighted view of the world.
Even funnier, the owner of BMN used that experience to form a company that was wildly successful. Almost certainly would never have happened if BMN was a paid service.
It's interesting, I'd say seeing everything as "must make business sense and make someone lots of money" is the short sighted view of the world. The world and life is so much more than just money and "number must go up".
Three cheers for that!
We may philosophically distinguish between that which serves some other end (like making money) and that which is an end in itself (the good or the beautiful). I myself try to arrange my life so as to have enough of the former to permit me to do as much as possible of the latter.
I think the vast majority of what I have done on the web has been some sort of labor of love or another. I do not miss the time or treasure it cost me, and highly value the people those projects touched, and the ways they shaped history in my little corner of the world.
Irritating little money-making services are everywhere, and they do make money. No one mourns them. Bugmenot is part of the immortal legend of the rise of the internet and the fight for what it is and what it means.
THIS! Also see: https://nonograph.com/write-some-software-give-it-away-for-f...
Well it was restricted until 1992. We probably should have left it that way.
Little known fact, it's actually completely forbidden to operate a business or have any connection to the Internet.
In North Korea.
Wanting to be free from tracking, awful people
"freeloaders" isn't a technical term, care to use one that is and stake a real claim here?
It shouldn't matter to much if you have an account on a website to get content and watch ad or not.
You get just more valuable as the product if you have an account.
I'm lost though why you are defending here neo-nazis and pure capitalism shitting over privacy for selling more private data for more money.